When you're ready to take your new sourdough starter for a spin, I have just the recipe. Consider this beginner loaf a bridge between regular white sandwich bread and Tartine-style artisan loaves. It uses a few cups of your bubbly sourdough starter along with commercial yeast to add some extra insurance as you're getting used to working with sourdough. This makes a soft and subtly tangy loaf that's perfect for tuna fish sandwiches and jam-smeared toast alike.
How Sour Is My Sourdough?
Don't worry if you make this loaf and find that your bread doesn't taste as strongly sour as you expected. For one thing, some of those complex sour flavors are only developed over the long, slow fermentation of a fully-sourdough bread. Since we're using some commercial yeast to speed things along in this recipe, we miss out on some of those flavors. Still, you can get close by giving your bread a slow-rise overnight in the fridge — I've noted in the recipe where you have the option to do this.
The flavor and sourness of your loaf will also depend a bit on your starter itself. Sourness is not a result of the wild yeast in the starter, but rather the build-up of acetic and lactic bacteria that are also living in the sourdough starter. If you are using your starter for the first time or refreshed it recently, it might not have quite the flavorful oomph! of a more mature starter. By contrast, if you're using starter from a batch that's gone a week or two without being refreshed, you'll probably notice a stronger sour flavor.
I usually make this particular bread on the weekends when I refresh my sourdough starter and use the portion of the starter I'd otherwise be discarding. I'm not always in the mood (and don't always have the time) to make a full sourdough loaf, so this one both uses up starter I'd otherwise be tossing and gives me fresh bread for the week.
Tester's Notes:
This recipe has needed an update for a while now and I'm sorry that it's taken me so long to get to it! Besides being a good stepping stone to baking full-on sourdough loaves without commercial yeast, I find that this recipe is perfect for those weekends when I need to use up some starter but don't have the time or energy to make a true sourdough bread. I like to shape this bread into loaves for easy sandwiches, but you can certainly shape it into rounds if you'd like a more artisan-style bread.
If you originally encountered this recipe anytime between now and 2008 when I first posted it, I recommend printing it out again. The original recipe, written in my newbie food writer days, definitely had some issues. My apologies for that! Coming back to it now, I've tweaked the amounts of the ingredients, streamlined the steps, and added some better descriptions so you know what to expect.
This is still one of my favorite weekly loaves. It's soft and tender with just a hint of that sourdough tang — just what I like in a good loaf of bread.
- Emma, February 2014
Beginner Sourdough Sandwich Loaf
Makes 2 loaves
1 1/4 cup (10 ounces) water
1 1/2 teaspoons yeast
2 cups (16 ounces) ripe sourdough starter (See Recipe Notes)
4 to 4 1/2 cups (18-20 1/4 ounces) all-purpose flour
1 tablespoon kosher salt (or 1 scant tablespoon table salt)
Combine the water and the yeast in the bowl of a stand mixer or in a large mixing bowl. Give the yeast a few minutes to dissolve completely. Stir in the sourdough starter until the starter is mostly dissolved (a few stringy bits are ok).
Add 4 cups of the flour and the salt, and stir to make a shaggy dough. With the dough hook attachment and your mixer on low speed, knead the dough for about 8 minutes. Alternatively, turn the dough out on a lightly floured counter and knead by hand. Add flour 1 tablespoon at a time as needed if the dough becomes sticky like bubble gum, but try to avoid adding too much. The dough is finished kneading when it comes together into a smooth ball that's slightly tacky to the touch and holds a ball-shape in your hand. (See more info: How to Tell When Dough is Kneaded.)
Clean out the mixing bowl, film it with a little oil, and return the dough to the bowl. Turn it a few times to coat with oil, then cover. Let the dough rise at warm room temperature until doubled in bulk, 1 1/2 to 2 hours.
Once risen, turn the dough out onto a lightly floured counter and divide it in two. Shape each half into rough balls and let them rest for 20 minutes. Meanwhile, grease two 8 1/2 x 4 1/2 loaf pans.
Shape each half into a sandwich loaf. (See more info: How to Shape a Sandwich Loaf.) Transfer the loaves to the loaf pans and cover loosely. Let the loaves rise until they're starting to puff over the rim of the pan, 1 to 1 1/2 hours. Alternatively, put your loaves in the refrigerator and let them rise slowly overnight.
When you see the loaves just starting to reach the rim of the loaf pans, begin preheating the oven to 450°F.
Slash the top of the loaves a few time with a serrated knife or baking lame, and slide them immediately into the oven. For a crispier crust, spritz the inside of the oven with water using a water spritzer before closing the oven. Bake for 10 minutes, then reduce the heat to 400°F. Continue baking for another 25 to 30 minutes, until the tops of the loaves are deep golden brown and the loaves sound hollow when tapped on the bottom. (Total baking time is 35 to 40 minutes.)
Shake the loaves out of the loaf pans and let them cool completely on a cooling rack.
Recipe Notes
- Make sure your starter is fully ripe before using. It should be bubbly and smell very sour.
- You can use any amount of starter in this recipe up to 2 cups. If you're using less, make up the difference with equal parts flour and water by weight.
- Whole Wheat and Whole Grain Loaves: You can swap up to 2 cups of the all-purpose flour in this recipe for whole wheat or another whole grain flour.
- Round Artisan Loaves: Alternatively, shape this bread into round loaves and bake them either on a baking stone or inside a Dutch oven. If baking in a Dutch oven, preheat the Dutch oven with the oven and bake as usual, removing the lid in the last half hour of baking.
This post and recipe have been updated. Originally published April 17, 2008.
via Recipe | The Kitchn http://ift.tt/1fmRYVQ
Put the internet to work for you.
What a beautiful loaf! I'm curious--what type/brand of loaf pans would you all recommend for someone who's starting out & would like to learn how to make sandwich loaves?
-Christina
04.17.08 10:36AMokay I think I am ready to try this but will have to wait for the weekend. My starter has been ending up with that liquid layer on top and none of it really smells sour...but maybe that's okay? I keep adding more flour and water and mixing it well...I guess I could try it and hope for the best!
04.17.08 11:36AMI didn't get my starter started until last night, but I glad you posted this recipe before it is ready to go. Thanks.
04.17.08 12:02PMYour bread is beautiful! I've never made a sourdough loaf in a pan - and am now of course wondering why not! I can't wait to try the recipe.
Christina,
I absolutely love my Chicago Metallic loaf pans and spread the word about them whenever I can, including here:
http://ift.tt/1poLi26
They work beautifully for all kinds of breads and cakes, and for the price of a couple of loaves of bread will give you years of us (they come with a 25 year warranty). I honestly don't know how I used to bake sandwich bread without them! : )
P.S. If you're looking for an easy basic white sandwich bread recipe, you might want to check out my Farmhouse White. Lots of people have had tasty success with it, and it's really easy to make variations to the recipe suit your personal taste (like using half white whole wheat flour, tossing in a little wheat and oat bran, etc.):
http://ift.tt/1poLfDI
Happy bread baking!
04.18.08 2:11PMSusan,
04.25.08 9:42AMThanks! The pans look great and aren't too expensive either. (A good thing, since one of the reasons I'm interested in baking is because good bakery bread is the price of solid gold around here!) The beer bread on your link looks tasty, too--I'll be trying that and the Farmhouse White soon!
-C.
I'm curious if anyone has a recipe without any yeast and preferably with an alternate to white flour. I'm thinking something along the lines of Rye or Spelt.
04.25.08 1:54PMCWillows, you can actually try making this same recipe without any yeast. Traditional sourdoughs actually don't use any commercial yeast at all.
I'll put some thought into alternates to white flour. It's hard to find good recipes that don't use any at all, but they're out there. Anyone else have any good white-flour alternative recipes?
04.28.08 9:00AMMy loaf didn't taste very sour at all, and I wonder if anyone else had similar results
05.12.08 12:43AMWithout having made this recipe, I can say I'm not surprised Sarahj's bread wasn't very sour. The rising time in the recipe isn't nearly long enough to get that sour sourdough flavor. The trick is to let it rise overnight in the fridge. I've done this using no extra yeast at all and with 3/4 tsp instant yeast and they both work fine. After I knead the dough, usually in the afternoon, I let it sit at room temp for an hour, then put in the fridge. The next morning, pull it out and let it sit at room temp again for at least two hours. By the end of that time it should be bubbled up like crazy, which is what you want if you're making boules or baguettes. (In this case, don't over handle the bread when you shape it into loaves.) If you're doing sandwich loaves, just punch the bubbles out before the second rise.
As for other recipes, this one's not bad (decreasing the yeast and increasing the rise time):
http://ift.tt/1poLi2n
And for other types of flour, Rose Levy Birnbaum has good ones in her Bread Bible -- the one where you add in bulgur to white flour as a way of making faux whole wheat (you're leaving out the bran, which is what makes bread dense and bitter) is great. Not avail online as far as I know but her book is a good investment. Otherwise, you can just experiment with other flours until you find what works -- there's really no wrong way, as long as you can make it rise.
08.29.09 9:58AMI have an outdoor grill (a big green egg) and I'll be trying this one out on it later today. Just wondering if the pan of water is then necessary in my situation?!
09.11.09 7:01PMDoes anyone know what adding some sugar would do? I like my bread somewhat sweet but i dont want to mess with the science!
05.02.11 12:33PMThis was the third loaf I made from my new wild starter. I started slowing activating/feeding my starter a few days before making the bread. I had a lot of success. It rose beautifully, and I even subbed wheat flour for about half of the white (high gluten) flour. But agree that it wasn't terribly sour. Good standard recipe. I halved it with no problems. Will probably try again but allow to rise overnight in the refrigerator and maybe mix in some rye or other flours.
11.18.11 9:33AMOk, I have a starter in the fridge, or a levain as the recipe calls it, and I can never tell if it is active enough to bake with. I've produced some loaves with it and with and without the extra dry active, but I want a chewy bread with big airy holes and I can never seem to achieve that - chewy airy hole advice?
12.13.11 10:50AMI have had a starter in the fridge for the past 3 days and am so excited to use it tonight. I followed this starter recipe http://ift.tt/1fmRWNG from a recommendation and am going to use the above for the loaves.
I want to do the overnight rest as most of the recipes I've seen out there instruct but I just can't wait. Maybe I'll put half in the fridge to rest overnight and bake tomorrow and bake the other half tonight...it'll be really great to see the difference in how sour it is.
I love warm, toasted sourdough bread with a good smear of butter.
I. cannot. wait.
03.21.12 1:43PMOkay ... not a newbie to bread or sourdough, but this recipe is totally awesome. I've been nurturing and feeding sourdough starter (original from King Arthur) for a few weeks. Been trying to find a bread recipe that would use the starter but also have great texture inside and crunch outside... and this is IT!
I made the loaves in two smallish pans (8-1/2 x 4-1/2) and a glass pan that is supposed to be 9x5. After removing them from pans and putting back in a cooling oven really made the crunch of the crust! But what amazes me is the inside. Moist, chewy, tasty, and holding together so well even after thin slicings.
I will be coming back to this recipe again and again. Thanks!
04.16.13 10:22PMI made the Starter, fed it for 5 days, and am in the process of making the sourdough loaves now (I am @ the 2 hour rise time now). I have not had any of the problems anyone else has had here, and have followed the directions for both. Although it did take a little more than 1c flour at kneading, all my recipes have. I am a newbie at bread and this is my very first starter and sour dough. I do have to say at the end of the first kneading I thought I had died and gone to heaven-the dough was so soft and pliable (I know -weird, right?). I just can't wait till it comes out of the oven!
02.24.14 9:52AMThanks for this sour bread recipt.
02.24.14 12:07PM